Steve Smith vs Kane Williamson: Who Is the Better Test Batter?

Two names, one era, one impossible argument. Steve Smith and Kane Williamson built their entire careers around the same three days a Test match tests hardest: patience, technique, and the ability to bat when everything else around you is falling apart.

Smith is still going, fidgeting through his guard, gathering runs the ugly way. Williamson just finished, retiring in June 2026 mid-series against England, calm to the very last ball.

So who actually batted better across a Test career? Let's get into it.

 

Quick Answer: Steve Smith vs Kane Williamson

Who Has the Better Overall Test Record?

On the raw numbers, Smith edges it. He's scored more runs, more centuries, and averages a shade higher.

Williamson isn't far behind on average, and he holds the New Zealand record for double centuries with six. Smith has four.

Add captaincy into the mix and it gets closer. Williamson won an ICC trophy as captain. Smith never got that far.

The Short Verdict

Smith is the better pure batter. Williamson is arguably the more complete cricketer once you weigh in leadership, temperament, and what he did with a weaker batting lineup around him.

Both belong in the same sentence as Kohli and Root. That's not really in question. Which one you'd pick first is.

 

Steve Smith vs Kane Williamson: Career Overview

Steve Smith's Journey to Test Greatness

Smith debuted for Australia in 2010 as a legspinner who batted at number 8. Nobody expected what came next.

By 2015 he was Australia's number one Test batter and the team's captain. His technique looked wrong on paper: a exaggerated leg-side shuffle before the ball's even bowled, hands and feet moving in ways no coaching manual would teach. It worked anyway.

Then came 2018 and Cape Town. Ball-tampering, a 12-month ban, captaincy stripped for two years. Smith came back in the 2019 Ashes and scored 774 runs in four innings, one of the great redemption arcs in the sport.

He crossed 10,000 Test runs in early 2025, becoming the 14th player in history and only the fourth Australian to do it. He's still adding to the tally in 2026.

Kane Williamson's Rise as New Zealand's Batting Legend

Williamson debuted a few months before Smith, also in 2010, against India in Ahmedabad. He scored a century on debut. Not many players start like that.

He took over New Zealand's captaincy in 2016 after Brendon McCullum's retirement, inheriting a team that punched above its weight through aggression. Williamson changed the method without losing the result: calm accumulation, low-risk batting, and a captaincy style built on trust rather than theatre.

He led New Zealand to two World Cup finals and, in 2021, to the World Test Championship title. That's the signature achievement of his career and arguably the biggest thing New Zealand cricket has ever won.

He retired from international cricket in June 2026, midway through a Test series in England, ending a 16-year career.

 

People also Search For  Steve Smith vs Virat Kohli: Who is the better Test batter?

 

Steve Smith vs Kane Williamson Test Stats Comparison

Matches, Runs and Batting Average

Smith has played 123 Tests and scored 10,763 runs at an average just above 56. Williamson finished his career on 110 Tests and 9,515 runs at an average of 54.06.

Smith has 13 more Tests and roughly 1,250 more runs. His average sits about two points higher too.

Neither number is soft. Both averages put them among the best top-order batters this century.

Test Centuries and Double Centuries

Smith has 37 Test hundreds, the second-most by an Australian behind Ricky Ponting's 41. Williamson finished with 33, the most by any New Zealand batter by some distance.

Double centuries flip the story. Williamson scored six, a New Zealand record. Smith has four.

So Smith wins on total hundreds, Williamson wins on the biggest ones.

Highest Score and Major Batting Milestones

Smith's highest Test score is 239, made against England at the WACA in the 2017-18 Ashes. Williamson's is 251, against the West Indies at Hamilton in December 2020, still the highest Test score by any New Zealand batter.

Smith went past 10,000 Test runs in Galle in January 2025, reaching the landmark in the same innings as a century. Williamson became New Zealand's all-time leading Test run-scorer, overtaking Ross Taylor, years before he retired.

Metric	Steve Smith	Kane Williamson
Tests	123	110
Runs	10,763	9,515
Average	~56.0	54.06
Hundreds	37	33
Double hundreds	4	6
Highest score	239	251
Status	Active	Retired (June 2026)

 

Batting Style: Why Steve Smith and Kane Williamson Score Runs Differently

Steve Smith's Unorthodox Technique

Watch Smith take guard and it looks off. He shuffles across the crease before the bowler's even released the ball, sometimes ending up outside off stump when the delivery arrives.

None of it matters once the ball's in flight. His hands are quick, his balance resets instantly, and he scores in areas that don't exist in a coaching textbook: hard hands through backward point, tucks off the hip that shouldn't work but do.

It's an ugly, brilliant method. Bowlers plan for a conventional stance and get a batter who's already solved the problem before the plan lands.

Kane Williamson's Classical and Risk-Free Approach

Williamson is the opposite. Compact, still, textbook. His bat comes down straight, his head stays over the ball, and he rarely plays a shot that looks like it carries risk.

That stillness is deceptive. He scores all around the ground without ever looking like he's hitting hard, using placement and timing instead of power.

Where Smith improvises under pressure, Williamson removes the pressure before it arrives. Different route, same destination: runs, repeatedly, against bowling attacks trying everything to stop them.

 

People also Search For  Who are cricket's Fab Four? Explained simply

 

Home vs Away Test Record

Steve Smith's Record Outside Australia

Smith is one of only a handful of batters in history to average above 50 both at home and away, a group that includes Sunil Gavaskar, Sachin Tendulkar, Rahul Dravid, Jacques Kallis, and Kumar Sangakkara.

His away numbers are built on huge scores in England (three separate Ashes series with 500-plus runs) and gritty runs in India, historically the toughest tour for any visiting batter.

Kane Williamson's Record Outside New Zealand

Williamson's away record is strong but shows more variation by country. He's scored centuries in Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Bangladesh, and led New Zealand to a series win in England in 2021.

Australia was the one wall he never fully broke through, a tour where New Zealand as a team has historically struggled regardless of who was batting.

Record	Steve Smith	Kane Williamson
Home average	Mid-to-high 60s	Mid-to-high 50s
Away average	Mid-to-high 50s	Mid-40s to low 50s
Home/away average gap	Small	Wider
Best away tour	England	England, Pakistan

 

Performance in SENA Countries

Steve Smith in England, South Africa, and New Zealand

England is where Smith built his legend. Repeated Ashes hundreds, a triple-figure average across some series, and the 2019 comeback that turned him into a folk villain for English crowds and a hero at home.

South Africa was complicated for obvious reasons tied to 2018, but Smith has scored runs there both before and after the ban. New Zealand has been a solid, unspectacular hunting ground for him too.

Kane Williamson in Australia, England, South Africa, and India

Williamson's SENA record leans toward England and South Africa, where his patience matched the conditions well. Australia remained the toughest tour of his career, a place where New Zealand rarely won and Williamson's overall numbers dipped compared to elsewhere.

India tested him the way it tests everyone: spin, low bounce, and reverse swing. He had moments there, including tough tour centuries, but it was never his most prolific away destination.

 

People also Search For  Joe Root vs Virat Kohli since 2020: who has really been the better Test batter?

 

Performance Against Top Test Teams

Steve Smith Against England, India and South Africa

Against England, Smith has been ruthless: 11 or more centuries against them, a strike rate for hundreds unmatched by most modern batters. Against India, he's scored heavily too, including tons on both home and away soil, at an average well above 50 in the fixture.

South Africa has been tougher, partly conditions, partly the emotional weight of Cape Town, but Smith has still managed centuries there since his return.

Kane Williamson Against Australia, India and England

Against Australia, Williamson's numbers are respectable but not dominant, a fair reflection of how hard New Zealand found that opponent across his career. Against India, he's been reliable rather than spectacular, doing enough to keep New Zealand competitive without racking up huge series tallies.

England is where Williamson's numbers against a top team look best, backed up by that 2021 series win on English soil, a result that mattered as much for the team as for his own average.

 

Captaincy Comparison

Steve Smith as Australia's Test Captain

Smith captained Australia in over 40 Tests across two spells, separated by the ball-tampering ban. His win percentage sits close to 58 to 59 percent, and his batting average as captain, above 70, is the second-best of anyone who's ever led a Test side, behind only Don Bradman.

He never got Australia to a WTC final in his time as full-time captain, and Cape Town remains the permanent asterisk on his leadership record, however good the runs were.

Kane Williamson as New Zealand's Test Captain

Williamson led New Zealand in 40 Tests, winning 22, for a win percentage around 55. His batting average as captain, above 57, ranks above Virat Kohli's and Joe Root's numbers in the same role.

Win percentage: Williamson's 55 percent sits just below Smith's, but Williamson did it with a squad that had far less individual firepower than Australia's.

WTC Final 2021: This is the defining difference. Williamson led New Zealand past India in the inaugural World Test Championship final at Southampton, giving the country its first-ever ICC Test trophy. Smith has never captained a side to an ICC title.

Leadership style: Smith led with intensity and tactical aggression, pushing fields and bowling changes hard. Williamson led with calm and trust, giving bowlers long spells and rarely showing visible frustration, a style credited with New Zealand's remarkable team culture through the 2010s and 2020s.

Team achievements: Williamson also took New Zealand to the 2019 ODI World Cup final and the 2021 T20 World Cup final, on top of the WTC title. Smith's captaincy achievements are more individual than collective, built on his own scores rather than team silverware.

 

Peak Performance Comparison

Steve Smith's Best Test Years

2014 to 2017 was Smith at his most dominant, a run that included topping the ICC Test rankings for three straight years and touching a rating of 947 in December 2017, second only to Bradman all-time. The 2019 Ashes comeback stands alone as a peak inside a peak: 774 runs in four innings straight off a 12-month layoff.

Kane Williamson's Golden Period

Williamson's best stretch ran from around 2019 to 2021, capped by reaching the number one Test batting ranking at the end of 2020 and leading New Zealand to the WTC title in 2021. It's the only period where his personal form and his team's results peaked at exactly the same time.

 

People also Search For  Steve Smith vs Joe Root: who is the better Test batter?

 

Steve Smith vs Kane Williamson: Head-to-Head Test Comparison

Metric	Steve Smith	Kane Williamson
Tests	123	110
Runs	10,763	9,515
Average	~56.0	54.06
Hundreds	37	33
Double hundreds	4	6
Highest score	239	251
Away average	Mid-to-high 50s	Mid-40s to low 50s
ICC No.1 ranking	Yes (2015-17, multiple stints)	Yes (Dec 2020)
Captaincy	40+ Tests, ~58-59% win	40 Tests, 55% win
WTC titles	0	1 (2021)

 

Who Is the Better Test Batter?

Pure Batting Ability

Smith wins this one. More runs, more hundreds, a higher average, and a technique so unusual it forced bowlers to rebuild plans from scratch every series. His peak ICC rating, second only to Bradman, is the clearest marker of just how far ahead of the field he got.

Consistency Across Conditions

This is closer. Both men average above 50 in most conditions they've played serious cricket in. Smith's home-away split is slightly tighter, but Williamson achieved his numbers with less batting support around him for most of his career.

Overseas Record

Smith takes it, mostly on the strength of his England record and his ability to keep his average above 50 almost everywhere. Williamson's overseas numbers are still excellent by any normal standard, just not quite at Smith's level in the toughest away conditions.

Captaincy and Leadership

Williamson wins clearly. A WTC title, two World Cup finals, and a batting average as captain that outranks Kohli and Root settle this one. Smith's captaincy record is good but carries the permanent shadow of Cape Town.

Overall Legacy

Smith will likely finish with the bigger raw numbers and a stronger case as the best pure batter of his generation not named Kohli. Williamson finishes as the player most credited with turning New Zealand into a genuine Test powerhouse, a country that had never won an ICC trophy in the format until he led them there.

Final verdict: If the question is who you'd pick to bat for your life in a Test match, most judges would lean Smith, on numbers alone. If the question is who mattered more to their team and country, Williamson has the stronger claim. Both retire, whenever Smith eventually does, as two of the four best Test batters of their era. Neither case is wrong.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Who has more Test runs, Steve Smith or Kane Williamson?

Steve Smith, with 10,763 runs to Kane Williamson's 9,515.

Who has the higher Test batting average?

Steve Smith, at just above 56, compared to Williamson's career-final average of 54.06.

Who has more Test centuries?

Steve Smith, with 37 to Williamson's 33. Williamson leads on double centuries, six to Smith's four.

Who performed better overseas?

Smith has the stronger away record overall, ranked among a small group of batters who average 50-plus both home and away. Williamson's away numbers are excellent too, just slightly more uneven by country.

Who was the better Test captain?

Kane Williamson, on results. He won the 2021 World Test Championship, New Zealand's first ICC trophy in the format, and also led the team to two World Cup finals. Smith has a higher win percentage but no ICC title as captain.

Is Steve Smith better than Kane Williamson?

As a pure batter, most of the numbers say yes. As an all-round cricketer, factoring in captaincy and what each player meant to their team, it's a genuine toss-up. Both stand comfortably among the four best Test batters of the last fifteen years.